Hello dear
Welcome To San Carlos Restaurant
At San Carlos Restaurant, located on Bainbridge Island, the rich tapestry of authentic Mexican cuisine unfolds. Established as a cherished local gem, this restaurant offers a welcoming atmosphere paired with exceptional service. Here, diners can savor signature dishes like the herbed crab chimichanga and the grilled steak and goat cheese enchiladas, each crafted with fresh, high-quality ingredients. The menu emphasizes vegetarian and heart-healthy options, making every meal a delightful experience. Guests rave about the vibrant flavors and home-style vibe that keeps them returning. San Carlos is not just a restaurant; it's a celebration of culinary excellence that endures through time.
Taste the best
Discover Our Menu
Guacamole
San Blas
US$19.95Shredded Machaca Beef
Fresh Chicken Soft Tacos (corn Or Flour)
US$17.95Seafood Burrito-smoked Salmon And Bay Shrimp
US$17.95Fresh Chicken Burrito
US$14.95Black Bean Burrito
US$12.95Vegetarian Burrito
US$14.95Lee's Favorite Locarb Salad (vegetarian Version)
US$16.95 About
San Carlos Restaurant
Welcome to San Carlos Restaurant, a hidden gem nestled in the heart of Bainbridge Island at 279 Madison Ave N. Known for its vibrant flavors and authentic Mexican cuisine, this establishment has earned a reputation that stands the test of time. With a welcoming atmosphere and a commitment to quality, San Carlos has become a must-visit destination for both locals and visitors alike.
- Address: 279 Madison Ave N, Bainbridge Island, WA 98110, United States
- Phone: +1 206-842-1999
Stepping into San Carlos, the first thing that greets you is the lively spirit of traditional Mexican culture. Despite some interior decor perhaps in need of a refresh, the warmth of the staff combined with the delicious food easily makes up for it. As Kelly Warner eloquently stated, "Really good Mexican food can be found here." Indeed, this sentiment resonates among many diners who flock here for an unforgettable meal.
The menu is a delightful tapestry of flavors, featuring appetizers like the Guacamole, Pico De Gallo, and the must-try Appetizer Tacos filled with succulent roast pork or grilled skirt steak. Each bite bursts with freshness, perfectly complementing the hearty nature of the dishes.
Diving deeper into the main courses, the Grilled Steak and Goat Cheese Enchiladas is a standout offering, artfully prepared on fresh roma tomato tortillas. The marinated grilled steak and creamy goat cheese topping make it a delectable choice at US$19.95. For seafood lovers, the Mesquite Smoked Salmon Enchiladas and the award-winning Herbed Crab Chimichanga are exquisite highlights, showcasing San Carlos's dedication to quality and flavor.
Guests have raved about the Always Special Entrees, with the Prawns Santa Fe taking the spotlight. This dish features jumbo sautéed prawns drizzled in a rich New Mexican red chili sauce, a dish Travis Vallejo described as "very delicious" with a home-style vibe that can keep you coming back for more.
The ambiance shifts outside, where many diners prefer to enjoy their meals al fresco. With outdoor seating that boasts a serene view, it's easy to see why the recommendation to "sit outside" is so prevalent among reviews. The delightful service also enhances the experience, as echoed by Ismail Baker, who praised the wonderful staff for going above and beyond by crafting extra margaritas to go, showcasing their commitment to hospitality.
With a menu that caters to various tastes, from savory fajitas to mouthwatering burritos, San Carlos Restaurant is more than just a dining establishment; it’s a culinary experience that keeps diners raving. Whether you’re a local or just passing through Bainbridge Island, your taste buds will thank you for indulging in a meal at San Carlos. Enjoy the flavors, the warmth, and the unforgettable moments shared over delicious dishes that truly celebrate the essence of Mexican cuisine.
People talk
Our Guestbook
“ Really good Mexican food can be found here. I mean, really good. I would recommend sitting outside, which is pretty. Inside is not. This restaurant badly needs a remodel inside, but going there for a really good Mexican meal is worth it. Just don't sit inside! Staff is wonderful and accommodating. This restaurant has been in business for many years. Nothing lasts that long without good food. All in all, I gave it five stars. ”
“ Very delicious Mexican food with that home-style vibe. Great service and fun atmosphere. Definitely a must try experience when hungry on Bainbridge Island. ”
“ This was our first time there. The staff was very tentative and polite. The food was absolutely amazing. Every single item tastes different and very very delicious, whereas in many Hispanic restaurants the food all taste the same. This was certainly NOT the case. Everything was authentic and cooked to perfection. This was hands down the best Mexican restaurant I have ever eaten at. I will certainly be back. It was so good I had to call my mom, who is Hispanic, just to rave about the food. AMAZING! ”
“ Absolutely the best fajitas I have ever had. Wonderful staff. Very friendly and welcoming. When I asked for a box, they even made an extra margaritas to go. These guys are above and beyond. Absolutely recommend and will definitely come back. Thank you. ”
“ Just found this great local gem....very clean....wonderful staff....and menu is great! Sit outside or inside...a great local Bainbridge Island place...my new favorite. ”
“ Had a great meal in the bar. Love the classic rock they play in there, a very nice vibe. We split our go-to San Carlos combination (grilled steak burrito, a mesquite smoked chicken and sour cream enchilada, and a pork verde enchilada) with a Mac and Jack’s African ale and a Cadillac margarita, and walked away full and happy. ”
“ Perfect timing despite availability. We were only a little pecking at dinner time, but knew that we would be hungry by 830 or 9pm. This lovely place was open with fantastic service despite only having one server working. She gave impeccable service, and we were quite pleased with our selection for dinner. Would definitely recommend! ”
“ The salsa is amazing and complemented by good, crispy chips. I got the mesquite chicken and sour cream enchiladas and the flavors were great. Not crazy about their rice but I filled up on the chips and enchiladas anyways definitely will be back again! ”